Knowing when to invest and when to walk away

Care home investment carries significant financial, regulatory, and reputational risk. Mac Research and Consultancy Limited presents two anonymised due diligence reports illustrating what credible investment decisions look like in practice.

Care home investment is not straightforward. Unlike many commercial asset classes, care services sit at the intersection of property, workforce, regulation, clinical governance, and public reputation. A building can be beautiful and a balance sheet can look robust, while underneath the surface a service is structurally fragile — under-staffed, poorly led, or already attracting the scrutiny of the Care Inspectorate or the Care Quality Commission.

At Mac Research and Consultancy Limited, we have supported investors, operators, and lenders across Scotland and England to conduct robust pre-acquisition due diligence that goes far beyond the standard financial and legal review. Our approach is built on sector intelligence, regulatory insight, and a deep understanding of what makes a care service genuinely sustainable.

"The most costly mistakes in care home investment are not made in the boardroom — they are made when investors fail to understand what is really happening on the floor."

The two reports below are composite anonymised case studies drawn from real due diligence contexts. They illustrate the range of findings that can emerge — and the very different conclusions a well-conducted review should produce.

The Scottish Care Home Investment Landscape

£3.4B

Estimated annual spend on adult care in Scotland

910+

Care Inspectorate-registered care homes in Scotland

38%

Of services requiring improvement on most recent CI inspection

4.7x

Average EBITDA multiple in recent Scottish care home transactions

62%

Of acquirers report post-acquisition compliance surprises

12–18

Months typical stabilisation period after change of ownership

These figures reinforce a consistent message: care home acquisition rewards those who invest in quality due diligence and penalises those who rely on headline financials alone. Regulatory risk, workforce instability, and reputational exposure are not peripheral concerns — they are core drivers of investment value and sustainability.

✓ Recommended for Acquisition

Of 40-bed older adult residential care · Scotland

XXX House is a 40-bed older adult residential care home operating in a rural XXXX setting with a strong local reputation, stable workforce, and consistent Care Inspectorate performance. The service has been under the same ownership for eleven years and is being offered for sale as part of a planned retirement succession. Mac Research was instructed by the prospective acquirer to conduct operational, regulatory, and workforce due diligence ahead of formal Heads of Terms.

Due Diligence Scorecard

Regulatory Standing

9/10

Workforce Stability

8.5/10

Financial Sustainability

8/10

Physical Environment

7.5/10

Governance & Leadership

8.5/10

Market & Demand Position

7/10

Key Positive Findings

✓

Strong CI Inspection HistoryMost recent Care Inspectorate inspection (2024) returned grades of 5 (Very Good) across Quality of Care and Support and Quality of Management and Leadership. No requirements or recommendations were outstanding at point of review.

✓

Low Staff TurnoverAnnualised staff turnover of 14% — significantly below the Scottish sector average of 29–34%. Fourteen members of staff have been in post for five or more years. The Registered Manager holds a Practice Development qualification and is committed to remaining post-acquisition.

✓

Compliant Recruitment Practices

Safer recruitment file audit of 20 personnel files confirmed full PVG certification, right-to-work documentation, and reference packs in all cases. No gaps in employment history were unaccounted for.

✓

Occupancy and Fee Position

Average occupancy over the preceding 24 months is 93.5%. Self-funded rates are competitive and have been uplifted annually. Local authority spot-purchase volume is modest and the service is not financially dependent on local authority fee levels.

!

Environment Requires Phased Investment

The building, while well-maintained and clean, was constructed in the 1980s. Two communal bathrooms require upgrading to current accessibility standards, and the laundry infrastructure should be replaced within 18–24 months. A capital improvement schedule of approximately £85,000 is recommended and should be reflected in price negotiation.

Mac Research Assessment — Invest

XXX House represents a well-governed, well-staffed, and regulatorily sound acquisition opportunity with identifiable, manageable improvement requirements. We recommend proceeding to Heads of Terms subject to financial warranty provisions addressing the building improvement programme and confirmation of Registered Manager retention. This is the type of care home that rewards a long-term, quality-focused operator.

✕ Do Not Proceed

XXXXX Care Centre

52-bed older adult residential & dementia care · Scotland

XXXXX Care Centre is a 52-bed mixed residential and dementia care service presented to the investor as a turnaround opportunity with strong occupancy and a recently refurbished building. Mac Research was engaged to conduct independent operational and regulatory due diligence. Our findings present a materially different picture from the information provided during the sales process, and we have advised our client in the strongest terms not to proceed with this acquisition.

Due Diligence Scorecard

Regulatory Standing

2.5/10

Workforce Stability

2/10

Financial Sustainability

4.5/10

Physical Environment

5.5/10

Governance & Leadership

1.8/10

Market & Demand Position

5/10

Critical Risk Findings

✕

Active Care Inspectorate Enforcement Action

A Freedom of Information review and direct regulatory contact confirmed that XXXX is currently subject to an Improvement Notice under the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 — information not disclosed by the vendor. Two of four inspection domains are graded 2 (Weak). A follow-up inspection visit is scheduled within the next 60 days. This creates immediate registration risk for any incoming operator.

✕

Systemic Staffing Crisis

Agency staff account for 46% of current care hours — a cost position that is financially unsustainable and a quality risk of the highest order. Four substantive care staff have resigned in the preceding 12 weeks. There is no Deputy Manager in post. The Registered Manager is on long-term sick absence and there is no confirmed interim leadership arrangement.

✕

Safeguarding Concerns on Record

Care plan and incident record review identified three unresolved adult protection referrals within the preceding six months. Incident recording was inconsistent, with evidence of gaps in contemporaneous documentation. Our review identified one potential Duty of Candour event that does not appear to have been managed in accordance with the Health (Tobacco, Nicotine etc. and Care) (Scotland) Act 2016.

✕

Financial Position Misrepresented

The occupancy figure of 87% presented in the information memorandum included eight beds occupied under a temporary local authority block-booking arrangement that expires in four months and will not be renewed. Adjusted occupancy is 72%.

EBITDA as presented overstates maintainable earnings by an estimated £180,000–£220,000 per annum.

✕

Medication Governance Failures

A review of the medication administration records (MARs) identified 23 unexplained gaps in controlled drug recording across a 30-day period. The medication management policy was last reviewed in 2021 and does not reflect current best practice or the 2023 Healthcare Improvement Scotland guidance. There was no evidence of pharmacist audit having been conducted in the preceding 18 months.

Mac Research Assessment — Do Not Proceed

The risks presented by XXXX Care Centre are not turnaround risks — they are fundamental structural failures in governance, regulatory compliance, workforce, and financial integrity. An incoming operator would inherit active enforcement action, a destabilised workforce, unresolved safeguarding matters, and a financial position materially different from that represented during the sales process. Mac Research advises that this acquisition should not proceed under any terms currently offered.

The Mac Research Due Diligence Framework

Our care home due diligence methodology goes substantially beyond the standard financial and legal review that most acquisition processes rely upon. We examine the dimensions that accountants and solicitors do not — and that experienced care sector investors know can make or break a service within months of acquisition.

Our framework is built around six integrated pillars, each assessed against current regulatory standards, sector benchmarks, and the specific risk profile of the service under review. We produce a written report with a clear advisory conclusion, supported by documentary evidence and scored domain findings.

01

Regulatory Intelligence

Full inspection history, active requirements, improvement notices, enforcement action, and intelligence from FOI and public registers.

02

Workforce & Leadership

Turnover analysis, agency dependency, key person risk, safer recruitment audit, training compliance, and leadership stability assessment.

03

Clinical & Care Governance

Care plan review, incident recording, medication governance, safeguarding history, Duty of Candour compliance, and quality assurance mechanisms.

04

Financial Sustainability

Occupancy analysis, fee composition, agency cost exposure, maintainable earnings assessment, and challenge of vendor financial representations.

05

Physical Environment

Environmental quality, statutory compliance, planned maintenance liabilities, infection prevention infrastructure, and capital investment requirements.

06

Market & Demand Position

Local demographic trends, competitor landscape, local authority relationships, self-funder demand, and post-acquisition growth potential.

Commission a Due Diligence Review

Whether you are acquiring a single service or building a portfolio, Mac Research and Consultancy Limited brings the sector expertise, regulatory insight, and operational rigour to protect your investment. We work with private investors, lenders, operators, and legal teams across Scotland and England.

Get in Touch

www.macresearchandconsultancy.co.uk | Expertise · Integrity · Impact

Mac Research & Consultancy Limited

Registered in Scotland | www.macresearchandconsultancy.co.uk

© 2026 Mac Research and Consultancy Limited. All rights reserved. For information purposes only.